March Books: 4/5? (Armageddon’s Children, obviously)
Howdy, squiders. How’s life?
If you’re new around here, or even if you’re not, here’s a quick recap. The Wishsong of Shannara was the book that introduced me to epic fantasy back when I was a kid, and seeing how I’m still hanging out in the epic fantasy genre decades later, it was definitely a formative book for me. So at some point I decided that I’m going to read through the whole series in chronological order. Armageddon’s Children (2006) is the fourth novel, coming in after the Word and the Void trilogy, which was originally written as a separate universe and then retroactively added into the Shannara storyline.
I’ve been reading about a book a year, but I suspect that will have to change. We’ll talk about that in a minute.
Armageddon’s Children and the other two books of the Genesis of Shannara trilogy are the bridge between the urban fantasy Word and Void trilogy–where there are demons and faerie creatures, and the Lady of the Word (good) and the Void (evil) vying for control of humanity and the world–and the more traditional high fantasy books in the Shannara series, many of which date from the late 70s through the early 90s. You’re welcome to go back and read my thoughts on those three books (search “Shannara” in the sidebar), but the Word and Void books are quieter, darker books that, aside from demon attacks and whatnot, explore issues such as grief, addiction, homelessness, and others. They take place in more or less modern day, in the real world.
At the end of Angel Fire East, I found myself hard-pressed to see how we were going to make the transition, but I was optimistic. The early Shannara books were some of my favorites as a kid. How much of that is nostalgia? No idea! I guess we’re figure that out when we get there.
So, having read Armageddon’s Children, how am I feeling?
Squiders, I am ANNOYED.
Spoilers, potentially, but the book is 20 years old, so do with it what you will.
I have no idea why the decision to add the Word and the Void books into the Shannara timeline was made. Their magic systems are completely different, and there is not a logical way to go from Point A to Point B. I got the impression from the Shannara books that there wasn’t magic before the apocalypse that ended everything, and that all the different races that exist had originally come from humans.
I suspect it came down the marketing. Maybe the Word and the Void books didn’t sell very well on their own. I have no idea. It’s not like Terry Brooks didn’t also have other multi-book fantasy series.
First of all, the structure of the book is aggravating. You can barely go five pages without getting a massive backstory dump about someone. You can only get away with this sort of crap when you’re 20 books into a best-selling series. There’s head-hopping and POV issues that I’d never be able to get away with. And most people’s backstories are very similar–they had relatively good and safe childhoods until their parent or parental figure was killed by demons or what have you. Repetitive.
There are also a lot of viewpoint characters, but that aligns with earlier Shannara books so is to be expected. We’ve got two Knights of Word, Logan Tom and Angel Perez, several members of a street gang called the Ghosts, and demons occasionally (including our best friend from the last two Word and the Void books). We jump kind of willy nilly among all of them, and honestly I kept forgetting about the Knights because we don’t see them all that often. The world here is still very much that of the Word and the Void, just 80-100 years later. Humanity has fallen, demons are everywhere, things are sad, boo hoo.
And THEN about halfway though, THERE ARE ELVES.
The same elves! From later! With the Ellcrys and elfstones and everything! THEY’VE BEEN HERE THE WHOLE TIME.
The transition from gritty, dark urban fantasy to the normal Shannara elves was so badly done I had to put the book down for a minute.
So, what, we couldn‘t figure out how to transition from Point A to B? The elves have just always existed? Squiders, I am so let down. It’s like we didn’t even try to figure anything out.
On one hand, I can see the reasoning. The Word and Void series has established faerie creatures as being real, from the sylvans that guard the forest to tatterdemalions that are created out of the memories of dead children. There are literal demons. So why not elves? The modern fantasy elf from Shannara and LOTR has its roots in the Tuatha De Danann from Irish mythology and the elves that are said to live in Iceland and other nordic countries. So it’s not a huge stretch to be like, oh, hey, there’s other faerie creatures, so why not elves?
But on the other hand, one, the elves just…live in the forest. Not like a magic, through the veil, otherworld forest, just the literal forest of the Columbia river basin. And two, from a worldbuilding standpoint, you have the Ohmsfords from the original Shannara trilogy who are part elf, so if the elves are a separate species and always have been, how are you interbreeding a thousand years in the future or whatever it is?
(Kit, you might say, this is fantasy, why are you worrying about interbreeding? After I wrote the first draft of Book 1, I gave it to some friends to read. At that time my main fantasy race had green blood, because they were inspired by Star Trek’s Vulcans–who also have green blood–and because they had green skin and it was a motif, okay? But I also had humans in the story, good ol’ red-blooded humans. And one of my friends said, Kit, how do you have two sentient species on the same planet whose evolutionary paths are so different and distant that they don’t even have the same circulatory mechanism? That’s unrealistic.
And arguably I could have been like IT’S MAGIC, LISA but she was right. And now everyone has red blood, which has nice symbolic connotations.
Anyway, my point is that you can get away with a lot in fantasy but you have to be internally consistent, and especially now that we have rooted the beginning of the series in the real world, with real world mechanisms, you’ve got to stick with them, for goodness’s sake.)
(Also, is it just the one set of elves in the Columbia River basin? How? Why would there not be other elves in other forests? I have questions.)
Anyway, I’m frustrated that the best we could come up with to transition magic systems is that the elves have been there the whole time, and they just are what they are. Missed opportunity to do something really cool with evolution and magic.
Now, to get back to the once a year thing. Each of the Word and the Void books were self-contained. This ended on every cliffhanger it could. Nothing was resolved. Nothing was accomplished, arguably. If I leave the series and meander off for another year, I am going to forget everything that is happening.
So, alas, I guess we’ll be on to The Elves of Cintra sooner rather than later.
Read the Genesis of Shannara books, squider? How do you feel about the elves? (Do the books get better?)





